• [stock-market-ticker symbols="AAPL;MSFT;GOOG;HPQ;^SPX;^DJI;LSE:BAG" stockExchange="NYSENasdaq" width"100%" palette="financial-light"]

    Islam Needs a Pope

    May 11, 2019
    Image by author

    Within the broad boundaries of Christendom, Catholics have the Pope, Anglicans have the Archbishop of Canterbury, some denominations have appointed and/or elected leaders, while still others, such as Congregationalists, insist on no hierarchy. Buddhists have several leaders, the most well-known being the Dalai Lama. Judaism is complicated by the melange of culture, race, and religion, so while there is no specific leader, chief rabbis speak to matters of doctrine.

    Islam has its scholars (for Sunnis, the Ulama) and Imams, but the famously fractious faith has no head. It needs one.

    In the absence of a global leader, Muslims are told to simply obey the Quran and hadiths. That might be a workable solution if both sources weren't subject to everlasting debate within and without Islam, and complicated for non-Muslims by the practice of taquiya and kithman. The month of Ramadan is upon us, and while the vast majority of Muslims regard it as a time for reflection and self-control demonstrated through fasting and other prescribed rituals, extremists view it as the ideal time for jihad. Such schisms aren't merely intellectual when spilled blood is a clockwork result.

    It is nearly impossible to imagine the human capable of rising from the ranks of the Muslim faithful to assume moral leadership in the modality of a Ghandi or Martin Luther King, Jr. The first and most obvious stumbling block is Sunni vs. Shia: Muslims would demand to know as a prerequisite the presumptive leader's sectional identity and cry foul if it didn't match their own. Establishing a lasting peace between the two primary branches would be a Herculean effort as each sees the other as apostates.

    Of course, that's more to the point, the need for a uniting voice. Apart from the gruesome violence and staggering body count of Muslim-on-Jew and Muslim-on-Christian terrorism, Muslim-on-Muslim violence is both common and vicious. Apostasy is a sin to both Sunnis and Shia, but Wahabbi Sunnis prefer to enforce the law on punishment of death. A reasonable voice with an ear receptive to both sides of Islam, and the power of enforcement to rule on--and mete out justice to--transgressors would be the hierarchical ideal case scenario. Even a figurehead, a neutered king of sorts, would be a preferable to the status quo.

    Road to Reform: An Old Idea Anew

    Failing hierarchical organizational restructuring, another solution exists: radical reform.

    Martin Luther.
    Image by Lucas Cranach der Ältere

    The Sufi, a small mystical sect of Islam, might hold the key. Sufis are beholden to neither Sunni nor Shia, the oddball in the mix. They are of unknown number, found scattered throughout the nation of Islam. The gravity of this historical moment (the latest global proliferation of Islam) and need for reform could coalesce around a Sufi Mawla, a spiritual leader who must be able to trace his teachers lineally back to Mohammad, and around whom a Sufi congregation forms. Neither Sunni nor Shia view Sufis as practicing Islam properly, but at the very least, they are not as diametrically opposed as Sunni vs. Shia.

    A charismatic Mawla, backed by influential Sunni and Shia leaders who recognize the need for even the appearance of change, could conceivably forge a path forward, though it is as tantalizing as it is unlikely. It is telling that any notion of healing the wound of schism in 632 A.D. is intractably fraught. That said, with over a billion followers worldwide and a growing global presence, a solution is imperative.

    Reform, not just de-escalating violence, is the logical course for the future of Islam. As Martin Luther decried the corruption of the Roman Catholic Church with his 95 Theses, so must a brave and principled Muslim arise and nail to the mosque door a plan to thwart Islamist terrorism, intra-Muslim violence, and forge a pact of mutual tolerance with the West.

    The alternative is to rewind history 900 years.



    Court Anderson

  • Subscribe
    Notify of

    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    Prince Eugene

    Reforming Islam. Ridiculous.

    Sufi Islam is ordinary orthodox Islam augmented with silly dancing and mesmerizing chants.

    Apostate Prophet › https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ooOgXkY-7Oo


    Islam already has a pope his name is Frahcis!

    Mark Berlinger

    Islam has a pope. Bergoglio is the Pope of Islam.



    Islam HAS a pope. The catholic church doesn't. They have a socialist for a leader, working independently from the bible.
    Islam needs a New Testament, something they will never get. Religion needs to be recognized for what it is. It is a stand-in to explain away those things that science doesn't explain yet, and to give people hope that there is life after the oxygen stops flowing. I'm sorry. That's just the raw reality of it all.


    Islam already has a Pope in the form of the current Pope. It's the Catholics that are in need of a Pope.


    A) A shallow understanding of Islam.
    B) The article is riddled with inaccuracies.
    C) All of the commentators are trolls.
    D) Islam doesn't have a corrupt catholic church, "The reformation" is a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.
    E) You only want a pope so you can start this process of reformation, but Islam doesn't need one.
    F) Islam has plenty of leading religious figures. You simply don't like them.
    G) How about I nominate Ayutallah Alkhaminai for example? see my point?
    H) Islam does need modernization. But not in the way you think.
    I) Modernization efforts should focus on solving contemporary problems, rather than pleasing anyone in the west or elsewhere.
    J) Thus we need More and better Ulama, and not a pope. Every country already has a Mufti anyway.

    John Acord

    A Muslim Pope would need an avaste army to subjugate those who do not readily follow his reform teachings and the will to lop off the heads of anyone who objected to his leadership. Yes, it might work. Maybe this could be a second Career for Obama? Seriously, I think that Erdogan would be perfect for the job. He has an army and the will. We just need to encourage him,


    Leave it fractured - that way they can focus on tearing each other apart rather than having a common enemy, US.


  • Subscribe to our evening newsletter to stay informed during these challenging times!!